He jumped at a knock on his door and automatically checked his watch, so it was good he hadn’t started pouring coffee into his mug. At least he didn’t have a mess to clean up. He put the unused mug and the full pot back in their spots, wiped his hands on his shirt, and went to answer. There wasn’t glass in the back door, but there was a peephole, and he leaned in to see how well it worked just in case that might help him figure out what the heck was going on.
Emily. Well then. Henry unlocked and opened the door, eyebrows already raised.
She grinned and held up her reusable shopping bag. “Screwdriver?”
“Uh.” He cleared his throat. “I haven’t even had any coffee yet.”
Her sigh was dramatic, but her smile stayed. “Can I come in anyway?”
Henry gestured. “Make yourself at home.” At least the bedroom door was closed, but shit, were the files out? He didn’t breathe until he saw that the folder was under a stack of books, everything tucked neatly inside. It was just a manila file folder, with nothing sticking out to tempt those big blue eyes.
Emily set the bag down on the coffee table, but she did a little circuit around the room instead of taking a seat right away. “You know, I think all of the cabins look exactly the same.”
He shrugged and went to actually pour his coffee this time. “The only price difference was for one or two people, so I assumed.”
She clucked her tongue. “Do you think anyone’s ever gone crazy here?”
“What, grabbed an ax and started murdering his family?” Henry sipped his coffee, but he didn’t want to sit down before she did.
Emily laughed. “In the book, it’s a roque mallet.”
He made a mental note that she read Stephen King, but otherwise let that slide. “I looked into this place before I signed anything.”
“I mean, I did, too, but that’s not going to be one of the reviews,” she laughed.
Not the ones on the main website, no, but something like that would leak. There would’ve been remnants left, even if Jonathan paid someone to try to take all evidence down. Plus a police report. There’d be something on file with the Meyer name connected to it, and there wasn’t. He’d checked.
Emily raised an eyebrow at his silence and went to pull the orange juice and vodka out of her bag, along with the clear plastic to-go cups. “What all just went through your mind right there?”
“What?” He tried not to blush, but the feel of his cheeks heating up just made it worse.
“You just had about a bazillion thoughts and said none of them.” Her eyes sparkled, but they were also intense.
Henry cleared his throat and went for a sip of coffee. “The NDA doesn’t hold if crimes are committed.”
“Yeah?” She tilted her head, shaking that curtain of blonde hair. “You actually read the whole thing?”
“You didn’t?” Shoot, was that too defensive?
Emily shook her head, sipped at her drink, and shrugged to show that the ratios were close enough. “I figure it’s a month out of time. We’re in a different stream. Live it, leave it.”
“So now you’re worried that there’s going to be a murder and you’ll have to forget it?” He tried to laugh it off.
“Has anyone actually seen Mary Shelley?” she shot right back.
Henry blinked to try to relieve his mental whiplash. “Uh.”
“I’m just saying.” She raised an eyebrow. “That’s suspicious, right?”
“Jonathan had to pick them up from somewhere.” Except his voice wavered, so that didn’t sound like he believed himself.
Emily shrugged and went to the window, one arm crossed over her stomach as the other hand raised her drink to her lips again. “Cool, so she was last seen alive almost a week ago.”
“She’s not dead in that cabin.” There, that was better.
“Said with such confidence because …?” she shot right back.
He blinked.
Emily nodded to herself and shrugged. “Did you know Gacy’s basement got searched because they had a warrant to look at some other part of his house, and one of the detectives recognized the smell of rotting meat?”
He licked his lips. “Emily …”
“I’ve walked past it. The path that goes most of the way around the lake? Yesterday.” She nodded out toward the water like she had to prove she knew what she was talking about.
Automatically Henry checked out her footwear: still the strappy heeled sandals. “And you smelled something?”
“No.” She tilted her head again. “But he’s had plenty of time to chop her up and start strewing the pieces around the woods.”
Henry took a slow breath. He had to remain focused. Distraction. That’s all this was. She realized she’d maybe said too much yesterday and needed to redirect his attention onto someone else: a murder that had either just happened or was about to happen. “I’m sure Percy didn’t kill his wife.”
“Really?” She turned those blue eyes on him, unsmiling. “Why?”
“What?” It dropped out of his mouth before he could stop it.
“Why are you so sure?” she pressed. “How much do you know about this guy?”
“Uh.” Stellar argument, that.
Emily nodded once. “Did you know Jane talked to Alyssa last night?”
Wait, what? Why would that matter?
“She asked her how much they know about any of us. Her and Truman, at least,” she clarified, like Henry was actually following along.
“And?” It wasn’t like he’d put anything on the forms that would raise any red flags. Right?
“She said they know our passwords for incoming calls, and she can look up our meal preferences, but that’s it.” She raised an eyebrow, and maybe she was in theater or something, because all these moves were dramatic. “They don’t even know anything.”
“Jonathan does background checks.” There. He knew that much.
Emily almost snorted. “Nobody really knows what goes on in a relationship until someone snaps.”
Wow. She’d just said that, looking straight into his eyes and everything, chin up and shoulders square.
Henry didn’t know what to say. Really, he had no idea. Even if they weren’t at Loon Lake, where secrets were the order of the day, he couldn’t very well have asked her to follow up on that, could he?
Emily twisted back to the window, a jerk of her shoulders followed by her head that nearly spilled her drink. She quickly swiped at her eyes like that meant they could both ignore the fact that they were even more magnified by tears, and ducked her head down to her glass, which probably either had too much or too little vodka right now.
Henry hid behind his mug, holding it in both hands, because hey, he now had a child murderer in his cabin, nice and early in the morning, and not only was she drinking, but she was getting upset about murder and relationships and people snapping. Was that the excuse? Annabeth Deschain killed Dani Jay because she snapped? You don’t know what’s going on in relationships—see how the world, and Dani Jay’s mother, apparently didn’t—until …
“You probably think I’m crazy.” Her voice was low, but her diction was immaculate.
Uh. “I don’t see the evidence for your accusation.”
“You want me to bring you evidence?” she challenged.
“Emily …” Maybe it wasn’t wise, but he set his coffee down so he could go over and take her hand. Just the one hand, since the other clutched her drink. “If Percy’s a murderer, then he’s dangerous. It’s too risky for you to sneak around trying to prove it.”
She frowned a little, then plucked her hand back. “You’re just saying that so you can poke around and come away as the hero.”
“What? No!” Except he couldn’t say he was saying it because he thought she was full of shit. That was too close to crazy.
The noise that came out of her was clearly a scoff. “So then you think I’m incompetent.”
Henry sighed and crossed his arms. “I think that, if you’re accusing someone of murder … especially the kind of premeditation you’re going for … then that person is incredibly dangerous and probably has contingency plans for someone catching on.” That didn’t really apply to Annabeth Deschain, who, everyone agreed, committed a murder of opportunity.
But who might either be trying to distract attention from herself, or seeking that same sort of high of being near a murder, but not the cause of it. Especially since she’d already gotten away with something.
“Look, Emily.” Okay, but what should come after that?
She shook her head and went for the front door, fumbling with the lock for a moment before getting it open and stalking unevenly to the lake shore and off to the right, maybe toward the lodge or maybe toward her own cabin, screwdriver only half-gone and ready to fuel her for whatever came next. Henry tried another deep breath and moved the rest of the orange juice to the fridge before finishing his coffee, considering his knitting, and sighing again as he picked it up and headed for his rocking chair.
Cold Comfort: Sunday, July 7, 2024 – Agatha, coming July 20