Henry’s layover in Chicago was ridiculous, but he wasn’t bored. He had his laptop, at least, and a couple hours into his basically overnight stay—he wasn’t going to pay for a hotel room for a mere nap, thanks—Percy’s face appeared on the giant television screens. It was a good five minutes before Henry realized he’d dropped into a full-on open-mouthed stare.
It was part of a breaking story, so he didn’t have long to wait before it came around again. “Suspected bank robbers Kyle Ferguson and Tammy Sype, identified days after the robbery on June 27, have finally been located … maybe,” the woman in the newsroom reported professionally, like she hadn’t said these exact same words not long before.
The photo on the left was clearly Percy Shelley. He was posed in front of the usual blue backdrop for studio portraits, smiling with his mouth but not his eyes and dressed in a suit and tie. The photo on the right was a stranger: a brown-haired woman in a selfie, beaming into her outstretched hand as she held her phone up over her head.
“During the robbery, Sype’s mask slipped,” the reporter explained with just enough modulation to keep from being boring. “Although her face was not caught on camera, witnesses in the bank provided enough of a description to help lead to identifying the couple, who apparently went off the grid at a tech-free retreat in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula.”
Yeah, they did. At least Percy did, and Henry supposed the whole mask slipping thing explained why they’d never seen Mary. They played the jerky black-and-white footage of the robbery behind the reporter’s monologue.
“The alleged robbers apparently panicked when they realized that another member of the retreat, there for her own reasons, was in fact one of the witnesses at the bank on June 27.”
Emily. Damn it, that was Emily. Her photo was cropped close to get rid of the friends on either side, but the blue eyes, the wide smile … Emily, with the name Kimberlee Jennings below her photo.
“Ferguson and Sype should be considered armed and dangerous. Anyone who sees Ferguson, Sype, or Jennings should call 911 immediately,” the reporter warned with finality. “Do not approach.”
It was definitely a headliner sort of story, but it left so much out. What about Agatha? Or even Jane and Henry himself? And the Meyers. Were they still missing?
Suddenly blinking, Henry opened his laptop, paid through the nose for the freaking Wi-Fi, and started Googling. He had names now, and putting in one popped up the other two: Kyle Ferguson, Tammy Sype, and Kimberlee Jennings. They were already connected, and members of the Jennings family put themselves in front of cameras and behind microphones to beg for help in finding Kimmy, who, he found out a couple clicks later, was apparently at Loon Lake because she was having an affair with her married professor.
Henry thought his head might explode.
The professor paid for his sweet young thing to escape to the Upper Peninsula for a month because the heat was on. His wife moved out and took the kids with her, there were complaints to his department chair, and a whole string of former students came forward to call out his inappropriate advances. Phew. But, Henry noticed, none of those young women—all hot with huge blue eyes, because Professor Youngren had a type—had their own cabins. In fact, they seemed rather salty about the fact that they weren’t the special one.
Mrs. Youngren had yet to be reached for comment.
Shortly before coming north, Kimberlee Jennings, aka Emily, had gone to the bank, where her transactions were scrutinized: she deposited a bunch of cash. She wouldn’t need any at Loon Lake, but nobody knew where she got the cash. Hush money from Youngren, maybe?
Kimberlee Jennings was clearly the most fascinating of the witnesses at the bank that day. People were already asking if she ran off illegally or something, while others protested that of course the police knew where to find her, except the police hadn’t known where to find Ferguson and Sype.
Henry sat there rubbing his chin. Jonathan had their names—or at least one name, right? He would’ve known that one of his guests was Kyle Ferguson, and he had to have known that Kyle Ferguson was wanted for questioning in a robbery. Especially if Jonathan knew that Kyle Ferguson was accompanied by Tammy Sype. One name might be a coincidence, but two? Tammy had to have signed the NDA and everything else, right? Jonathan wouldn’t accept any residents who hadn’t.
Unless the pair of them planned it and used fake identities to book.
Hmm. If it was a good enough fake, maybe they had all the records. They could have planned it all, because they were going to hit the bank and disappear off the grid for a month before emerging under their new names, anyway.
Henry hadn’t seen the photos of Ferguson and Sype before. He wasn’t entirely sure of the timeline. Had they been identified before he got to Loon Lake, or had he just not been aware because the story wasn’t big enough to cross state lines initially? But he did understand why Percy would be upset at the idea of the residents having to show their real names.
Or their faces. Both their faces.
Henry shook his head as he continued looking through the Internet to see if anyone, anywhere had more information than this. It didn’t look like they did, which meant he, personally, was a gold mine. A gold mine who’d have his cell phone back soon enough and was reachable by email now.
Henry should probably start sending some of his own emails now.
On July 1 of this year, I arrived at Loon Lake Retreat as a resident alongside Ferguson, Sype, and Jennings. Brilliant. He didn’t even have to start out by saying he’d never met Sype and he thought Jennings was actually Annabeth Deschain. The main point was he’d been there, but he was out now and therefore both reachable and willing to write … for the highest bidder. This summer might pay for itself after all.
Cold Comfort: Saturday, July 13, 2024 – Agatha (3), coming August 26