Where There’s Smoke – Chapter Fifty-Two

Jo

Allan grabs the wheeled stool and brings it right up next to my chair, adding his hands on top of ours. “My God, Jamie … Jo …”

He’s pale, and strained, and I think he might’ve been crying, but I can’t tell if it’s because of what happened to us or if—

“I just talked to the police,” he continues, voice rasping, and one of us is going to need a hand free for the Kleenex again any second now.

Jamie closes his eyes. “Allan, I’m sorry.”

“Fuck that,” he snaps back. “Do you know what they showed me? It’s probably illegal. They’ve got this little black and white clip of Shane in a room with these two other guys, and you know what he’s saying?”

Jamie frowns, and of course I’m frowning too, and am I having a hard time following everything because I’ve lost some brain cells today or because this is legitimately confusing?

“He’s telling them Mom told him about Dad after the funeral.” Allan shakes his head and his mouth twitches like he’s got another surge of tears. “Right there on camera: look, yeah, she told me, but only after he died.”

“The fuck?” Jamie says softly.

“Yeah, they already brought him down to the station, I guess.” Allan shakes his head again and focuses on Jamie. “Nobody knows where Mom is. She’s not with him. They showed up and said hey, we have some questions, and either he just broke down or hell if I know, but the point is, you’ve got nothing to be sorry for.” The way his lips press together makes me think that Shane is another story.

Wait, hang on. “You’re saying your mom knew? Since when?” And God, shut up, Jo. It’s not your family tragedy this time.

Allan shrugs and starts to slouch back before he remembers he’s on a stool. “No fucking idea. They’re just showing me this, trying to get me to be like oh, yeah, me too, but none of this makes any fucking sense.”

No, it really doesn’t.

“Listen, Jo.” Allan takes one of his hands back to rub it over his face. “I really hope you don’t, but if you get out now, you can avoid being hit with all this shit.”

A laugh bursts out of Jamie. “No, no, I’m sorry,” he protests, but it’s a release, and he can’t help the giggles. “Jo, I’m sorry.”

Allan starts to stand, like maybe he needs to hit the call button, but I shake my head and reach out to urge him back down. “Davis tried to stop my adoption. He said he’s my biological father.”

It’s his turn to blink a few times, unable to connect the dots. “Wait, what?”

“He showed up to my adoption hearing,” I explain. “He said my parents couldn’t have me because he’s blood, and he wanted to take me. He didn’t follow through with the DNA testing, but I’m screwed no matter what.”

“You …” Slowly he looks to Jamie, who’s at least gotten himself under control, and then back to me. “You showed up to ask Jamie about Milwaukee because you were trying to clear your own dad’s name?”

I lift up a hand and rock it back and forth. “I knew he did two of them.”

“And her mother,” Jamie adds. “The third name he confessed to. That was her mother.”

Right. That. It’s just a part of my life, but watching Allan’s face reminds me that hey, actually, it’s trauma. Even if I didn’t get the confirmation until this summer, I’ve basically always suspected it, and what does that say about a kid who’s not even in the double digits yet?

“Oh my God.” Allan drops his face into both hands. “This is really going to make headlines.” Then he looks up. “Wait, wait, wait—shit, Jo, you’ve already been through this.”

What, realizing my birth father was a serial killer? “My name’s never been connected to his. Nobody knew those headlines were personal.”

That makes Jamie wince. “I’m not sure you’re going to be able to keep up that streak.”

Allan tilts his head toward the door. “I saw your parents out there. You want me to get them?”

I shake my head before I realize I’m shaking it. They already know about me, obviously—they were there when Davis showed up—but I don’t want to deal with them confronting this idea about Elias Whittaker. I mean, I don’t think the police would come up with some sort of AI deepfake of Shane saying that kind of thing, but it’s also not super clear. Maybe Helen told Shane something after Elias’s funeral, but if the clip doesn’t actually have Shane saying Dad’s the Milwaukee Millennium Murderer outright, then they just fooled Allan with a clever edit.

Look, I didn’t just accept that Davis was a serial murderer as soon as I stumbled on it. That’s even with all the years thinking he killed my mother, you know? Granted, I don’t know much about Elias Whittaker, but the way these two are just accepting it is sobering.

Jamie shakes my hand a little to bring me back to the present. “It’s okay,” he says softly, even though I’m not sure what it is or if anything’s okay right now. “They don’t know what’s going on.”

Technically we don’t know what’s going on, either, but God, Jamie just told Bradley and Moline that his dad’s a suspect? Not even that: that his dad is the Milwaukee Millennium Murderer, and his mom drugged him and tried to kill him to stop us from finding out. No. That’s just not something a mother would do. If Helen wanted to throw me off the trail, she’d think of something else, not …

She wouldn’t try to kill Jamie. What are we saying here? That, since last night, she figured out how to drug his coffee and get the gas on and fake a message to me on his phone? Helen, who’s not very tech-savvy?

And it’s Jamie, the son who moved back in with her to look after her and take care of her since Elias died. The one nominated by his brothers, in fact. He stepped in, he stepped up …

He’s the adopted kid. If Helen did this, she tried to kill her adopted kid just to get back at me. I can’t live with that. Can I?

“Allan,” Jamie rasps, “I need to ask you to give her a hug.”


Chapter Fifty-Three – coming November 22

Leave a Reply